Mastering Church Volunteer Management: Essential Tips to Schedule and Empower Your Volunteers

Written by: Matt Strelecki Date: March 21, 2025

Volunteer leading a church volunteer management meeting

Imagine this: It's Sunday morning and half your church service teams are missing. The volunteer database looks full, yet no one shows up for their assigned roles. Sound familiar? Church volunteer management isn't just about filling slots. It's about creating a culture where people want to serve. Whether you're struggling with volunteer retention, last-minute no-shows or burnout, this guide will help you transform your ministry volunteers into a thriving, engaged team. And the best part? It's easier than you think.

Table of Contents

How can I effectively recruit church volunteers?
What are the best practices for scheduling church volunteers?
How can I improve church volunteer retention and engagement?
What tools and software can help with church volunteer management?
How can I create an effective church volunteer program?
What are common challenges in managing church volunteers and how to overcome them?
How can effective volunteer management help grow your church?
Checklist to build a culture of volunteerism within the church
Free Church Growth Pack: 400+ tools to unlock church engagement!

How Can I Effectively Recruit Church Volunteers?

The first step involves finding volunteers that are suited to your church. There are several recruitment strategies to consider, including the following.

What are the Best Strategies to Attract New Volunteers?

Recruitment strategies include:

Word-of-mouth recruitment: Word of mouth can be very effective. Talk to members of your congregation and current staff to let them know about any openings you may have. This personal touch can help you find people who connect with your church's mission and vision.
Social media: Social media isn't as personal, but offers a broad reach, ensuring you get the word out about your volunteer needs. Advertise your position as a learning experience to increase interactions.
Announcements during services: An announcement makes a good portion of your congregation aware of your volunteer needs. The community-centric approach increases your chances of finding the ideal match.
Post on job boards: Various job boards are set up specifically for church jobs, including MinistryJobs, and ChurchStaffing. They are ideal ways to connect with volunteers.

How Can I Align Volunteer Opportunities with Church Members' Skills?

You may find several individuals who have responded to your volunteer-seeking inquiries. But how can you ensure you match each person with the perfect position? Ideally, you would want musicians for worship, extroverts for greeting and organized members for planning.

People may talk about their abilities and even provide resumes, but surveys can be more telling. You can create a multi-choice study that volunteers need to complete to describe their reactions to specific circumstances. Standard pre-employment questionnaires include personality tests, cognitive ability tests and skills assessment tests.

You can purchase these tests or create them yourself. Once you do, you may administer them via Church Survey Questions and Templates for Every Occasion. These free templates are ideal for vetting volunteers, gathering members' feedback and using various other tasks.

What Role Does the Pastor Play in Volunteer Recruitment?

The church pastor should play a significant role in the volunteer recruitment process. They could be viewed similarly to an employer who ensures employees follow company culture. The pastor should:

Cast the vision for faith-based volunteering: The vision dictates what the church and volunteers get from the volunteering experience and what they want to accomplish. The pastor can set a vision by sharing personal stories demonstrating what the church and faith are about.
Gives Volunteering a Spiritual Foundation: Volunteering at a church should go beyond helping a good cause and learning skills. It should have a spiritual foundation as well. For example, a pastor may cite Philippians 2:4: "Not looking to your interests but each of you to the interests of others." The pastor should endorse participation with their words and support.
Mentorship: Pastors can also serve as mentors as volunteers grow within the church. They can provide support when volunteers have difficult times. Pastors can ensure they have the hard and soft skills they need to thrive in the church community and beyond.

What are the Best Practices for Church Volunteers?

Church volunteers can help a church significantly, taking the weight off staff members' shoulders. However, they also increase some responsibilities. For example, staff members may be tasked with volunteer scheduling.

Fortunately, there are ways to simplify scheduling. Here are some suggestions.

How Can I Use Volunteer Management Software to Simplify Scheduling?

Church volunteer software may be the most efficient way to simplify scheduling. Here are the steps you need to take:

Identify scheduling needs: Determine your peak work hours and the required skill sets.
Choose scheduling software: Choose a platform that is easy to use and automates your scheduling requirements.
Gather employee availability: Find out when workers are available to ensure you don't overlap with their schedule.
Create shift templates: Consider creating shift templates that allow you to insert employee names for different times of the day.
Assign shifts based on skills and preferences: Choose volunteers to work, ensuring their skills match the assigned tasks and shifts fit their scheduling needs.
Publish the schedule: Your schedule should be sharable. Once published, it should be available to all volunteers.

An automated system reduces conflicts and improves volunteer communication, ensuring everyone is on the same page.

Of course, you need to choose a scheduling software program before you do any of that. Here are two recommended choices.

ACS Technologies: ACS Technologies allows you to build unique volunteer roles based on your organization's needs. You can also organize volunteers into teams to facilitate communication. The technology minimizes conflicts and allows volunteers to communicate through the platform if a conflict arises.
Planning Center: Planning Center is a comprehensive management system with scheduling features. You can use its 'Groups' feature to organize and communicate with groups, as well as its service planning and volunteer scheduling for any team.

What are Effective Ways to Manage Volunteer Availability?

The following steps will ensure you manage volunteer availability effectively.

Use scheduling apps with availability features: Ensure your scheduling apps have availability features that make you aware of preferred shifts and allow workers to communicate when they are unavailable.
Create a rotating schedule: A fixed schedule may increase organization, but a rotating schedule prevents burnout, a significant issue in the workplace. In a survey, 23 percent of 7,500 full-time employees who participated say they feel burned out at work often or always, while 44 percent say they sometimes feel burned out. A rotating schedule can reduce burnout and may be a preferred choice for some workers.
Have backup volunteers on hand: Avoid putting all your eggs in one basket. Have backup volunteers available if another volunteer can't take their assigned shift.

How Can I Ensure Fairness in Volunteer Scheduling?

Favoritism is unwanted in any workplace. Some 47 percent of American employees say they have experienced favoritism in the workplace, leading to adverse effects. It can be incredibly discouraging to those who work for your organization for free.

Churches should encourage volunteers to keep working by treating them fairly when scheduling. Here are some helpful tips that will help you achieve that goal.

Distribute duties evenly: Ensure each volunteer has similar hours each week. Distribute duties so no volunteer is overwhelmed by overly complex tasks or is assigned simple functions that don't challenge them.
Promote a balance of experienced and new volunteers: When experienced and new volunteers work together, experienced staff can train and mentor newer volunteers, ensuring they learn the ropes.
Consider family schedules and availability preferences: Every volunteer should provide you with availability and scheduling preferences when they sign on. Doing so minimizes the chances of you accidentally assigning shifts that workers can't attend.

How Can I Improve Volunteer Retention and Engagement?

Volunteer recruitment can be difficult, but retention is even more challenging. Without pay, volunteers may decide they have more pressing obligations. They may not be there when you need them and some may quit just after you have put in the hard work to get them up to speed.

Fortunately, there are ways to improve volunteer retention. Here are a few suggestions.

What are the Key Elements of Volunteer Appreciation?

Volunteers will be less likely to leave if you show your appreciation. Here are some volunteer appreciation techniques you may want to implement.

Volunteer appreciation events: Events are ideal for letting employees know how much you appreciate them. You can throw a party for your volunteers, invite them to lunch or give them VIP treatment at one of your fundraisers.
Shoutouts during service: Church leaders should mention volunteers, acknowledging how the church couldn't have reached its goals without them.
Digital shoutouts: You may also show appreciation to volunteers through mentions in social media, blogs and other online assets.
Handwritten thank-you notes: You can tell volunteers how much you appreciate them via email, but a handwritten thank you note offers personalization that makes the appreciation more meaningful. They will likely use a magnet to display the thank you note on their fridge so they can remember how they helped your organization.

How Can I Empower Volunteers to Take on Leadership Roles?

Volunteers should eventually take on church leadership roles. The church will benefit by developing staff members who can take on more tasks and guide new volunteers, while the volunteer benefits by learning new skills and feeling more fulfilled.

Church volunteers may be reluctant to step up, but church administrators can encourage them to move forward by empowering them as follows:

Offer mentorship programs: Mentorship programs involve experienced volunteers and church leaders training new volunteers. According to statistics, 87 percent of mentors and mentees feel empowered by their relationships and have developed higher confidence levels. These programs forge a connection that makes the volunteering experience more meaningful while getting new staff members up to speed.

Encourage clear leadership paths: Volunteers may not recognize leadership opportunities, but administrators can encourage clear leadership paths to help them move forward. For example, they can explain how learning specific skills and taking on new tasks can prepare volunteers for roles as team leads and coordinators.

Delegating responsibilities: Church administrators should also delegate responsibilities to encourage volunteers to develop in their roles. Encourage them to take on new, potentially intimidating challenges (with proper support) to ensure they learn new skills. A sense of responsibility and supporting those in charge of church administration can also make them more committed to the church.

What Strategies Help Volunteers Feel Valued and Connected to the Church Community?

Volunteers will feel more committed to a church that makes them feel valued and connected. Administrators can encourage and promote commitment through the following church group activities.

Retreats: A church retreat can be work-related or spiritual. For example, many companies host work retreats to encourage team building, boost morale and provide relaxation to avoid burnout. A spiritual retreat offers a space for deep reflection, introspection and personal growth. Both retreat types can make volunteers feel more connected to the church community.
Small groups: Small groups promote a sense of intimacy and encourage more personal experiences. If you have several volunteers, consider dividing them into small groups for get-togethers.
Training sessions: Volunteer training programs can become more fun if they focus on team building and allow employees to work together to reach common goals.

What Tools and Software Can Help with Church Volunteer Management?

You can simplify church volunteer management with the proper tools and software. Here are some to consider integrating into your technology suite.

How Does Church Volunteer Management Software Benefit the Local Church?

Church volunteer software is a recommended tool and it provides the following benefits.

Time-saving automation: Church volunteer software automates scheduling by allowing volunteers to sign up for shifts online, receive automated notifications about upcoming shifts, check for conflicts and offer skills-based matching features. It reduces the time spent scheduling volunteers and minimizes time-consuming errors.
Improves communication: Most software programs allow volunteers to communicate with administrators so they can request shifts and update their availability. The programs also remind volunteers about upcoming shifts, reducing the risk of no-shows.

Several churches have used scheduling software to improve efficiency. One example is All Saints Catholic Church. Initially, they were using different software programs to schedule volunteers and ministry. Their software had no communication features. As a bilingual church, communications became more challenging to handle.

After switching to church volunteer software, they benefited from increased communication and organization that helped bring their congregation closer.

The Church of Saint Mary also benefited from scheduling software. They initially used a sign-in sheet to check in volunteers. People would sign the wrong boxes, making it difficult to track who showed up and who didn't.

The software system improved the check-in process. It also allowed church members to view volunteer schedules and automatically sign up for specific volunteer duties.

What Features Should I Look for in a Volunteer Management System?

Not all volunteer management systems are created equal. Here are some features to consider when ensuring your system meets your needs.

Scheduling automation: Automated scheduling allows volunteers to schedule the shifts they prefer. It also sends out emails and notifications to remind volunteers about upcoming shifts.
Communication tools: Communication tools allow volunteers to message directly to schedule updates and changes.
Attendance tracking: Many scheduling systems allow volunteers to clock in and out digitally so the software can calculate their hours and identify absences and tardiness.
Role assignments: Some software systems learn volunteers' skills, helping administrators assign tasks to the most qualified.

Beyond features, you can also determine if scheduling software is right for you based on the following:

Cost: Choose software that provides the best value for your money.
Integration: Ensure the software integrates with your current systems to provide a seamless integration.
Ease of use: A system that's easy to use will require minimal training and adjustments.

Look at online reviews to determine if a system is right for you. You may also talk to organizations and businesses that use scheduling software to get their take on it.

How Can Technology Simplify Volunteer Coordination for Church Events?

Volunteer scheduling software can schedule volunteers for day-to-day operations and provide volunteer coordination for church event planning. Here are some benefits it offers.

Centralized volunteer management: The software enters volunteer information, including contact information, availability and assigned roles, into a centralized database. Organizers can view all registered volunteers in one place and assign them specific event tasks.
Automated scheduling and task assignment: Organizers can enter the system to create specific shifts and tasks. For example, they can make shifts for greeters, ushers or parking attendants who can work early or later in the event. Volunteers can sign up for their preferred shifts for optimal convenience.
Improved communication and coordination: Built-in email and SMS alerts remind volunteers of upcoming shifts and alert them to last-minute changes. Some platforms offer direct messaging features for more effective communication between team leaders and volunteers. Dashboards allow volunteers to access schedules, task lists and essential information from anywhere, ensuring everyone is on the same page.
Streamlines check-in process: Event coordinators won't have to worry about who's here and who's not. Volunteers can check in digitally with QR codes and mobile apps. Organizers can immediately reassign tasks if no-shows or cancellations occur.
Post-event reporting and follow-up: Attendance tracking provides insight into volunteer engagement and attendance. This information can be used to recognize and reward dedicated volunteers. Organizers may also use the software to send out surveys to gather feedback and determine areas of improvement for future events.

Vanco's Event Ticketing Software is free for all no-charge events, allowing churches to try it without risk. It offers online registration, customized event pages, data and analytics, easy attendee management and secure payments. Try it out to see how it benefits your organization.

Use our Event Ticketing Software alongside our Event Tools and Templates for optimal results. We offer templates for event letters, permission slips, event planning worksheets, event evaluation forms and promotional fliers. The best part is that you can download it for free!

How Can I Create an Effective Church Volunteer Program?

Engaged volunteers start with an effective program. Here are some strategies that ensure optimal engagement.

What are the Essential Components of a Flourishing Volunteer Ministry?

A flourishing volunteer ministry requires the following elements:

Vision: The vision of your volunteer ministry should go beyond daily tasks. It should align with your church's vision and focus on creating strong leaders.
Structure: The program should be structured to meet church needs and allow for leadership development.
Leadership: Volunteers guided by church leaders and experienced volunteers become more engaged with the church and experience a sense of acceptance, community and fulfillment.
Evaluation and feedback: Volunteer feedback plays a crucial role in retention. Recent research reveals that individuals receiving low feedback are 63 percent more likely to leave their organizations than those who receive high-quality feedback. Administrators should evaluate volunteers and ask for feedback regularly. This system ensures all parties can identify areas of improvement and support smoother processes.

Training and onboarding are also necessary. Church leaders may be too busy to onboard or train new team members properly, but volunteers often feel lost without the proper orientation. They may decide they are no longer interested in the position, leaving you to start the recruitment process from scratch.

Churches can ensure an optimal volunteer onboarding experience by:

Creating teams of new and experienced volunteers: Experienced volunteers can help new members learn the ropes.
Using videos and AI: Church administrators who don't have the time to train new volunteers should consider using videos and AI to explain tasks.
Creating Mentor Programs: Administrators may assign new volunteers to mentors so they can learn tasks and gain other valuable insights.

How Can I Align the Volunteer Program with the Church's Mission?

The church's mission should be present in all church activities, including its volunteer activities. Depending on the role, a volunteer may do more or less to amplify the church's mission. Here are some examples:

Assistance with worship services: Volunteers may usher, lead hymns, play music or operate audio and visual equipment. These tasks require some understanding of the church's mission.
Religious education: Volunteers may teach Sunday school lessons, lead church youth programs or organize Bible studies. They need to understand the spiritual message the church is sending.
Church community outreach: Tasks may include visiting the sick or elderly, delivering meals, organizing food drives and participating in other community events. Volunteers serve as church representatives in these circumstances and need to maintain the proper image.
Administration: Administrative tasks like answering phone calls, managing the church calendar, maintaining records and assisting with mailing may not require as much familiarity with the church's religious mission, but volunteers need to still present a church-friendly demeanor.
Events and hospitality: Volunteers who set up for events, serve food, greet guests and help with registration sign-ups need to represent the church in the desired manner.
Children's ministry: Children's ministry includes supervising childcare and leading children's activities. Volunteers need to ensure they represent themselves properly when dealing with community youth.
Cleaning, repairs and maintenance: Even volunteers delegated to these duties need to maintain the proper attitude around visitors, staff and other volunteers.

Volunteers will quickly adapt to church culture integrated into training and tasks. Administrators and leaders need to guide by example to ensure volunteers follow suit.

What Role Do Church Leaders Play in Supporting the Volunteer Program?

Church leaders need to play a decisive role in supporting the volunteer program. Proper interactions with church leaders can encourage volunteers to get on board and stick with the program. They need to remain visible and provide feedback and recognition to let volunteers know they appreciate their efforts.

Leaders should also go beyond support and recognition, taking on a mentorship role. They can guide volunteers through the following:

Active listening: Active listening involves asking questions, paraphrasing and paying attention to body language. It makes volunteers feel recognized and ensures potential issues are addressed.
Goal setting: Leaders should set clear goals to motivate volunteers and help them develop.
Feedback: Volunteers need to receive positive feedback and constructive criticism to understand their strengths and weaknesses.
Knowledge-sharing: Leaders should share knowledge and stories to build a personal connection and help mentees learn from their mistakes.
Empowerment: Volunteers should be encouraged to take matters into their own hands and make decisions when necessary. This approach empowers them to innovate and develop leadership skills.
Networking opportunities: Leaders should introduce volunteers to people in the community that may help them advance in their careers.

What are the Common Challenges in Managing Church Volunteers and How to Overcome Them?

Churches may encounter challenges in volunteer acquisition and retention. Unfortunately, that's only part of the struggle. Issues may also arise during an employee's organizational tenure, including conflicts, burnout and unreliability.

However, you can deal with these issues in the following manner.

How Can I Handle Conflict Among Volunteers?

Conflicts arise for many reasons. Personalities clash and people have disagreements. The important thing is to resolve disputes in a way that pleases all involved parties.

Here are some effective strategies to consider:

Practice active listening: Listen carefully to what both parties have to say to ensure they feel their needs are understood. If necessary, have private discussions with both parties to avoid shouting matches.
Collaboration: Work together to find a solution that pleases everyone. Encourage both parties to let go of their pride to find a resolution.
Mediation: You may be the best mediator for the conflict, but in some instances, you may consider bringing in an unbiased third party. However, you should avoid bringing in too many outside parties, as doing so can lead to conflicting opinions that can inflame tempers.
Set goals: Your immediate conflict may be solved, but you may still encounter issues if the involved parties are holding onto grudges. You can help them overcome grudges by setting clear goals. Sometimes, the solution may be to limit communications between the two parties. However, hopefully, there is a goal for reconnection.
Suggest bonding activities: If reconnection is the goal, suggest bonding activities to encourage the two parties to get along.
Encourage Prayer: Encourage parties to turn to God to guide them in helping them overcome their differences.

Read our article 10 Church Conflict Resolution Tips for Faith Leaders to learn how to resolve conflicts in your organization.

What Strategies Help in Managing Volunteer Burnout?

Volunteers may also become burned out by repeatedly working long hours and doing the same tasks. Church administrators can prevent volunteer burnout by:

Recognizing the signs of burnout: Leaders should look for signs of burnout, which include exhaustion, a lack of motivation, depression, anxiety and irritability. They should understand that workers who display these symptoms need a break.
Adjust schedules accordingly: You can reduce burnout by giving volunteers a lighter schedule or scheduling them for different tasks or other times of the day.
Encourage regular breaks: Ensure workers receive regular breaks throughout the day. Make them aware that they can take time off for vacations and mental wellness.

How Can I Address the Issues of Unreliable Volunteers?

A lack of reliability among volunteers may be one of the most significant issues facing church administrators. According to the Corporation of Community Service, the average volunteer retention rate is 65 percent. That means one in three volunteers will stop providing service to your organization, sometimes without warning.

There is no foolproof way to address this issue. However, church administrators can increase reliability by:

Establishing clear expectations and accountability: Volunteers should understand the church is counting on them. They need to set clear expectations by letting volunteers know what their duties entail. It's best to reach an understanding before volunteers begin training with the organization to avoid misunderstandings that could leave you in the lurch.
Understand reasons for inconsistencies: Church leaders need to understand the reason for inconsistencies. For example, they can prepare a backup plan if inconsistencies are tied to inclement weather or a spreading illness. If volunteers aren't loyal to your organization, it may also be because they don't feel appreciated. Consider offering more perks to ensure they stay onboard.
Create a backup plan: Overcome the immediate issues no-shows present with a backup plan. Ensure there is always someone you can call when volunteers don't show up or cancel at the last minute.

How Can Effective Volunteer Management Help Grow Your Church?

Dealing with volunteers can be challenging, but it pays off with church growth. The following sections will explain how volunteers support your church.

What Impact Does a Strong Volunteer Program Have on Church Community?

Engaged volunteers create a more welcoming church community in the following ways:

A pleasant environment: Volunteers take care of tasks like cleaning, repairs and administration, ensuring the church looks and operates at its best and creating a more pleasant atmosphere.
Welcoming guests: Volunteers can improve church hospitality. They can greet people at the door so they feel welcome.
More profound sense of Community: Visitors may also enjoy seeing community members they know from outside the church volunteering in the church environment. Volunteers may also have deeper connections with the community than church leaders, encouraging attendance.
Outreach assistance: Volunteers can help with church outreach programs by raising funds and connecting with involved parties to make them more effective.

How Can Volunteers Contribute to Outreach and Evangelism Efforts?

Volunteers can assist with various outreach projects and evangelism efforts. For example, they may:

Participate in homeless ministries, helping to support and care for people experiencing homelessness.
Help with food drives by marketing the event, collecting and distributing food.
Help organize and accompany leaders on church mission trips to ensure they run smoothly.

To be successful, volunteers need to be trained in evangelism and community engagement. Train volunteers to engage and preach the word of God by:

Ensuring they have a theological understanding
Teaching them to build relationships through active listening and showing a genuine interest in people's lives.
Church leaders may provide a personal testimony of how God helped them overcome difficulties
Addressing objections through respectful dialogue and open-mindedness
Conducting role-playing scenarios to address everyday situations and objections

What Role Do Volunteers Play in Supporting Church Growth Initiatives

Volunteers play an active role in supporting church growth initiatives. They may work hands-on to support the initiative or take care of other tasks, allowing church leaders to focus on initiatives. Here are some examples:

Children's ministries: Volunteers can support churches by leading successful children's ministry programs. Children who grow up around the church tend to support it. These programs establish the church's legacy, ensuring that they attract loyal members.
Worship teams: Worship teams actively take part in church services. Volunteers may support worship team coordination, participate in worship teams or both. This connection builds loyalty, helping the church's long-term growth.

Several churches have experienced exceptional growth through volunteer support. For example, Mariners Church called volunteers "their heartbeat." The Lutheran Women in Mission values their volunteers by listing all the perks of joining. With the right church volunteer management approach, your church will attract volunteers who support your organization and transform it into a thriving community institution.

Checklist to build a culture of volunteerism within the church

➡ Create a structured volunteer recruitment process.
➡ Develop a clear mission statement for the volunteer program.
➡ Use volunteer software for scheduling and coordination.
➡ Provide ongoing training and leadership development.
➡ Host regular appreciation events and recognition programs.
➡ Foster community among volunteers through small groups.
➡ Implement feedback mechanisms for continuous improvement.
➡ Ensure alignment with church goals and mission.
➡ Encourage mentorship and leadership pathways.

Free Church Growth Pack: 400+ tools to unlock church engagement!

Imagine a church where every member feels connected, ministries thrive and engagement isn't just a goal; it's a reality. That's precisely what this Free Church Growth Pack can help you achieve. Inside, you'll find 400+ tools designed to make participation more manageable, more meaningful and more impactful.